The NFLPA, Deshaun Watson decided to appeal the one-year suspension in court

Getty Images

Final penalty, if any, imposed on quarterback Brown Deshaun Watson It will depend first on Judge Su L.’s decision. Robinson and then, if any discipline whatsoever is imposed and appeals to the Union, to the commissioner or his designee. In the end, the courts can get involved.

Yahoo Sports’ Charles Robinson reports that the NFL Players Association and Watson Camp Already decided to file a lawsuit The league is in federal court, if the end result of the process is a suspension for an entire season.

While the Syndicate and Watson are entitled to try, winning won’t be easy. For starters, judges love it when private parties agree on their own procedures to resolve disputes. The NFL and NFLPA negotiated a process to enforce discipline under the Personal Conduct Policy. The two sides agreed to review the approach in 2020, with the discipline officer entering the account. In general, courts won’t be tempted to take the burden on themselves by speculating that the steps that administration and business have crafted will unfold — and the Federal Arbitration Act gives them cover to stay out of such fights.

Complicating matters is the history created by the issues resulting from the suspension Tom Brady And the Ezekiel Elliot. Brady, after defeating his #Deflategate suspension in federal court in Manhattan, lost to a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Elliott, who successfully circumvented the New York federal court system and preceded the Brady case, was granted an exemption in a Texas federal court from his suspension of a personal conduct policy. However, it was determined that he sued too quickly when he filed his case to challenge the league’s final decision before the NFL could sue to defend it. The case reverted to the case brought by the NFL in New York, and that was the case.

This is where the NFL has a built in advantage. Papers can be ready to be served in the Southern District of New York, and they can literally press the button seconds after the internship is official. Basically, the league could easily win what is ultimately a rigged race to the courtroom.

The fact that the league and federation have negotiated a new CBA since the Elliot affair will make it difficult to attack the existing procedures. If there were serious concerns about the rules and regulations for enforcing discipline under the Personal Conduct Policy, the Federation could have addressed them when drafting the new terms. To win, the NFLPA will need to show that the league has in some way violated its rules and regulations.

It wouldn’t suffice to say, “We don’t like the final decision.” The two sides agreed that the disciplinary officer would make the first decision, that the commissioner or his representative would take over the appeal, and that the appeal decision would be final. Federal courts are not supposed to be the next level of appeal. The case is supposed to be over. Thus, based on the Brady and Elliott cases, it would not be easy for Watson to get a federal court to overturn a one-year suspension, if that is the end result of the agreed internal procedure.